Crotch strap may have saved kayaker
Lookout! Issue 38, July 2018
The man’s buoyancy vest had ridden up when his body was found in the surf hundreds of metres from the river mouth. He was also some distance from his kayak, which was suitable for use only in sheltered waters.
The Coroner has found that a proper lifejacket with a crotch strap may have helped save the victim’s life. A high-rated lifejacket, such as a Type 401, keeps the wearer vertical in the water and able to breathe – even if they are unconscious.
While an experienced lake and river kayaker, this area was new to the man, who was visiting with friends. He had taken his kayak toward the river mouth that morning to go fishing, and had returned safely to the ‘crib’ for lunch. But when he headed out again about 3pm, he did not make it back.
The alarm was raised when his friend went for a walk and found the man’s kayak floating in surf on the sea side of a large gravel bar separating the ocean and river mouth lagoon. A helicopter search located his body down the coastline, submerged in the surf.
He was wearing jeans, socks and a T-shirt, along with his buoyancy vest. There was no footwear, but he had been seen wearing gumboots when he went out to his kayak. The Coroner found that the man was wearing inappropriate clothing for the environment and the activity. Cold water immersion contributes to fatalities, and denim and cotton provide little insulation.
The bar has a reputation for being deceptively dangerous – with at least one whitebaiter getting carried out to sea each year. There is often a marked fall between the lagoon level and sea levels – resulting in a strong current in the apparently calm lagoon.
Small vessels can easily be dragged to the ‘point-of no-return’ at the bar, without the occupants realising it. The strongest tidal flow was from 4pm that day – when the man had returned to the water.
While the lagoon was relatively sheltered from the strong south-west breeze, conditions on the bar were extremely dangerous. The river flow, strengthened by the outgoing tide, was pushing against the onshore wind, and this contributed to the waves of 4–6 metres present on the bar.
The victim was not carrying any type of communication device to call for help.
- This man failed to follow many basic safety precautions. He should have made enquiries about the local conditions, and understood the dangers around the river mouth and bar – especially with the outgoing tide.
- A highest-rating, type 401, lifejacket is recommended. These have the benefit of a collar to keep the wearer’s head supported and above water in an emergency, and a crotch strap to prevent the safety garment from riding up.
- Paddlers and boaties should carry two forms of waterproof communication. For kayakers this could include a hand-held VHF radio, a cellphone in a waterproof lanyard bag, or a personal locator beacon (PLB).
- Waterproof communication devices should be attached to a lifejacket, on a lanyard, or stashed in a pocket.
- Kayaks are prone to capsize – especially open-decked, generalpurpose models. To prevent hypothermia, the safest practice is for paddlers to wear a wetsuit, or layer up with woollen or synthetic clothing, such as polar fleece.
- This type of recreational kayak was probably fit for the intended voyage within the lagoon, but not for the sea conditions at the river mouth that afternoon. This model lacked a substantial keel or rudder, and, together with its wide profile, was not designed for efficient handling in turbulent waters.
- River bars are notoriously dangerous for larger vessels, let alone small paddle craft like kayaks or jetskis. Anybody on the water near a bar is well advised to research local conditions. For videos and recommendations about bar crossings go to: www.maritimenz.govt. nz/recreational/safety/crossing-thebar.asp + search for boatsafetyinnz on YouTube.