Milestone in drive for ship-based crane safety

Safe Seas Clean Seas Issue 49, December 2015

New Zealand is celebrating a significant victory at the International Maritime Organization in London.

After more than eight years’ work, member states have agreed there is a need for an amendment to the Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS) Convention covering onboard lifting appliances – cranes, loose gear and winches.

A recent meeting of the Maritime Safety Committee saw a majority of member states in favour of amending the SOLAS convention to include requirements for lifting equipment, a proposal led by Maritime New Zealand delegates.

A SOLAS regulation will be developed around the design, construction and installation of onboard lifting appliances. In addition, this type of equipment will be maintained in accordance with guidelines that will also be developed to cover design, fabrication and construction; onboard procedures for routine inspection, maintenance and operation of lifting appliances and winches; and familiarisation of ship’s crew and shore-based personnel.

While New Zealand law currently addresses standards for lifting gear and enables action when a problem occurs in relation to foreign ships operating in New Zealand ports, the changes to SOLAS will lift standards internationally. This will work to prevent vessels arriving at New Zealand ports with inadequate lifting equipment, and strengthen Maritime NZ’s ability to deal with problems through Port State control mechanisms.

Maritime NZ staff have been striving since 2007 to get this work started after recording 334 incidents at New Zealand ports on foreign-flagged vessels between 2000 and 2007, of which 64 involved ships’ lifting appliances. Eighteen of these incidents involved serious injury.

Concerns about lifting gear on foreign-flagged vessels prompted a focused inspection campaign and the results were presented in 2007 to the IMO’s Maritime Safety Committee which instructed New Zealand to submit a request for a new work programme item.

In 2011, New Zealand successfully co-sponsored a proposal to add a work programme item to the IMO agenda to develop requirements for construction and installation of onboard lifting appliances.

Successful lobbying of members states on the issue by Maritime NZ resulted in the recent outcome.

“This is a tribute to the commitment of Maritime NZ staff who identified a significant safety issue that required attention and persevered until it was agreed that SOLAS should be amended,” Maritime NZ Director Keith Manch said.

“The work will not be complete until an amendment to the SOLAS convention that covers lifting equipment is adopted, but this is a significant milestone. I am confident this work will make the industry safer at ports all over the world.

“Failure of ship cargo handling appliances puts stevedores at risk, as well as the crew of foreign ships handling cargoes in NZ ports. New Zealand imports and exports are also at significant risk of damage due to lifting appliance failure, and this work will help reduce that risk.

“It is likely to take several years to finalise the changes to SOLAS, but we have made a significant step in the right direction.”

Since January 2013, seven incidents involving lifting equipment have occurred in New Zealand ports, with one resulting in a significant injury to a ship’s crew member.

Case study

Near miss from falling crane

Truck damaged by crane
Australian Maritime Safety Authority ©2020
The driver was fortunate to escape with only minor head injuries when the jib of this ship-based crane collapsed.

The dislodging of the primary drive gear is considered to have been the cause of this deck crane collapsing on to an Australian wharf about a decade ago, crushing a stores truck and causing minor head injuries and bruising to the nearby driver. The hook block narrowly missed the Chief Officer and two crew, who were organising loads from the wharf.

Accidents such as this one are the reason New Zealand co-sponsored a proposal to add a work programme item to the International Maritime Organization agenda to develop requirements for construction and installation of onboard lifting appliances. A Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS) Convention regulation is to be developed around the design, construction and installation of onboard lifting appliances.

Crane landed on truck
The view from the crane
Australian Maritime Safety Authority ©2020

This 25-tonne capacity crane on a foreign-flagged ship was standing free, waiting while the pallet sling, with a two-tonne load, was being prepared to be attached to the crane hook.

When the crane’s luffing drum electric motor was removed in Dubai a couple of months earlier, to replace burnt-out motor windings, it is possible the drive shaft was knocked or pushed inwards while the repaired motor was being put back into place.

The Australian Maritime Safety Authority said the force may have been sufficient to dislocate the retaining arrangement on the drive shaft – probably some form of locking ring – which eventually resulted in the lateral movement of the drive shaft, and the collapse of the main structure, the jib.

The crane itself was barely damaged in the accident, but further use was prohibited until all of the components of the gear box had been thoroughly examined and the crane had been load tested as required. The jib was later restored on the ship deck with the help of a mobile crane.

Back to index

Cover of Issue 49
Return to the index for Safe Seas Clean Seas Issue 49, December 2015
Return to index
Previous: New satellite station boosts search and rescue capability
Next: PLB ‘so small but so important’